Also known as: supplemental claim, VA Form 20-0995, new and relevant evidence, supplemental claim filing, reopen denied claim, supplemental claim timeline, how to file supplemental claim, supplemental after HLR
Have a specific question about Supplemental Claim Appeals?
Free. Answers cite their sources, such as 38 CFR, VA.gov and other veterans-benefits references.
Supplemental Claim Appeals
Supplemental Claim Appeals
Supplemental Claim Appeals: A Comprehensive Guide
If you disagree with a VA decision on your claim, a Supplemental Claim is a formal way to ask the VA to review your case again by submitting new and relevant evidence or requesting review based on a change in law. This guide provides detailed information about Supplemental Claims, including eligibility, evidence requirements, filing procedures, timelines, and strategic considerations.
A Supplemental Claim is a type of VA decision review option that allows Veterans and other VA beneficiaries to request a new review of a previously decided claim by submitting new and relevant evidence or by requesting review based on a change in law (e.g., new presumptive conditions under the PACT Act).
What Is a Supplemental Claim? - Key Points
Key Points
It is not a new claim but a request to reconsider a previously decided claim.
It is available only if the VA has already made a decision on your claim.
It is not available for contested claims (claims where the VA has not made a final decision).
You must submit new and relevant evidence or identify evidence for VA to gather, or request review due to a change in law.
When to File a Supplemental Claim
When to File a Supplemental Claim
You should consider filing a Supplemental Claim if:
You have new and relevant evidence that was not previously considered.
You want the VA to review your claim based on a change in law or VA policy (such as the PACT Act adding new presumptive conditions).
You want to reopen a claim that was previously denied.
You want to add evidence after a prior decision without requesting a higher-level review or Board appeal.
When to File a Supplemental Claim - Eligibility Requirements
Eligibility Requirements
You must meet both of the following:
The VA has already made a decision on your claim.
Your claim is not a contested claim.
And you must meet at least one of the following:
You have new and relevant evidence to submit.
You are requesting review based on a change in law.
New and Relevant Evidence Requirement - Definitions
New and Relevant Evidence Requirement
Definitions
New Evidence: Evidence that was not previously part of your VA claim file or considered by the VA in the prior decision.
Relevant Evidence: Evidence that tends to prove or disprove a matter at issue in your claim.
New and Relevant Evidence Requirement - Important Notes
Important Notes
Without new and relevant evidence, your Supplemental Claim will be considered incomplete and may be denied.
If your Supplemental Claim is based on a change in law (e.g., new presumptive conditions), you do not need new evidence but must identify the change and provide supporting documentation.
You can also identify evidence you want the VA to help gather (e.g., medical records from VA or private providers).
What Counts as New and Relevant Evidence?
What Counts as New and Relevant Evidence?
Examples of new and relevant evidence include:
New Medical Records or Reports: For example, a new medical opinion linking your condition to service.
Buddy or Lay Statements: Statements from fellow service members or witnesses describing incidents or symptoms.
New Diagnostic Test Results: Imaging, lab tests, or other medical evidence not previously submitted.
Service Records: Newly obtained service treatment records or personnel documents.
Evidence of Changed Circumstances: For example, a new diagnosis or worsening of a condition (note: worsening conditions may require a new claim for increased disability, not a Supplemental Claim).
What Counts as New and Relevant Evidence? - Examples
Examples
Scenario
New and Relevant Evidence Example
Previously denied mental health condition
New medical report linking condition to service
Denied claim for back pain
Buddy statement describing incident and symptoms
Claim based on toxic exposure
New VA medical exam documenting diagnosis
VA Form 20-0995: How to File a Supplemental Claim
VA Form 20-0995: How to File a Supplemental Claim
To file a Supplemental Claim, you must complete and submit VA Form 20-0995 — Decision Review Request: Supplemental Claim.
VA Form 20-0995: How to File a Supplemental Claim - Key Details About VA Form 20-0995
Key Details About VA Form 20-0995
Available on the VA website or at VA regional offices.
Must be filled out completely, including:
Claimant information
Identification of the prior decision being appealed
Description of new and relevant evidence or change in law
List of evidence you are submitting or want VA to obtain
You can submit the form by mail, in person, or with the assistance of a Veterans Service Organization (VSO).
VA Form 20-0995: How to File a Supplemental Claim - Supporting Documentation
Supporting Documentation
Attach all new and relevant evidence you have.
Provide names and treatment dates if you want VA to obtain records.
Filing Deadline Considerations
Filing Deadline Considerations
You must file your Supplemental Claim within one year from the date of the VA decision you are disputing.
If you file after one year, the VA may consider it a new claim rather than a Supplemental Claim.
Timely filing preserves your effective date for benefits.
If you miss the deadline, consider other options such as a new claim or Board appeal.
Using a Supplemental Claim After a Higher-Level Review Denial
Using a Supplemental Claim After a Higher-Level Review Denial
If you request a Higher-Level Review (HLR) and it is denied, you may still file a Supplemental Claim.
The Supplemental Claim must include new and relevant evidence not previously submitted during the HLR.
This allows you to continue pursuing benefits without immediately appealing to the Board of Veterans’ Appeals.
Filing a Supplemental Claim after HLR denial resets the one-year appeal period.
Supplemental Claims for Previously Denied Conditions
Supplemental Claims for Previously Denied Conditions
Supplemental Claims can be used to reopen claims for conditions previously denied by submitting new and relevant evidence.
You cannot use a Supplemental Claim to request an increase for a service-connected condition that has worsened; instead, file a claim for increased disability compensation.
For conditions newly covered under changes in law (e.g., PACT Act presumptive conditions), you may file a Supplemental Claim without new evidence but with documentation of diagnosis and qualifying service.
Timeline Expectations for Supplemental Claims
Timeline Expectations for Supplemental Claims
VA aims to complete Supplemental Claims within 125 days on average.
Actual processing times may vary depending on complexity and evidence gathering.
You will receive a decision letter explaining the outcome.
If additional evidence is needed, VA may contact you or your representative.
Duty to Assist in Supplemental Claims
Duty to Assist in Supplemental Claims
The VA has a duty to assist claimants in obtaining evidence relevant to their claim, including:
Helping to obtain VA medical records.
Requesting private medical records if you provide provider information.
Obtaining service treatment records.
Scheduling VA medical examinations if necessary.
You must identify the evidence you want VA to gather and provide sufficient information (e.g., provider names, dates).
Strategic Use of Supplemental Claims
Strategic Use of Supplemental Claims
Supplemental Claims are best used when you have new and relevant evidence that could change the outcome.
They allow you to avoid the risk of losing benefits by appealing directly to the Board.
Use Supplemental Claims to add evidence after a VA decision without starting a new claim.
Consider consulting a Veterans Service Officer (VSO) or accredited representative to help identify evidence and navigate the process.
If you have a change in law affecting your condition, a Supplemental Claim is the appropriate review option.
Avoid using Supplemental Claims for increased disability claims; file a new claim instead.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 1. What is the difference between a Supplemental Claim and a Higher-Level Review?
1. What is the difference between a Supplemental Claim and a Higher-Level Review?
Supplemental Claim: Requires new and relevant evidence or a change in law; VA will assist in gathering evidence.
Higher-Level Review: Does not allow new evidence; a senior reviewer looks for errors in the original decision.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 2. Can I submit new evidence after filing a Supplemental Claim?
2. Can I submit new evidence after filing a Supplemental Claim?
Yes, you can submit additional evidence while your Supplemental Claim is pending, but it must be new and relevant.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 3. What happens if I file a Supplemental Claim without new and relevant evidence?
3. What happens if I file a Supplemental Claim without new and relevant evidence?
The VA will likely deny the claim as incomplete or without merit.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 5. How long do I have to file a Supplemental Claim?
4. Can I file a Supplemental Claim for increased disability compensation?
No. For worsening conditions, file a new claim for increased disability benefits.
5. How long do I have to file a Supplemental Claim?
You must file within one year of the VA decision you are appealing.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 6. Does filing a Supplemental Claim stop the appeal clock?
6. Does filing a Supplemental Claim stop the appeal clock?
Yes, filing a Supplemental Claim restarts the one-year appeal period for further appeals.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 7. Can I file a Supplemental Claim for a condition newly covered by the PACT Act?
7. Can I file a Supplemental Claim for a condition newly covered by the PACT Act?
Yes. You can file a Supplemental Claim based on the change in law without new evidence, but you must provide medical evidence of diagnosis and qualifying service.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - 8. How do I get help filing a Supplemental Claim?
8. How do I get help filing a Supplemental Claim?
You can get assistance from accredited VSOs, VA representatives, or attorneys specializing in VA claims.
References
References
38 CFR § 3.2500 - Supplemental claims
VA Form 20-0995 - Decision Review Request: Supplemental Claim
This guide is designed to help Veterans and beneficiaries understand the Supplemental Claim process and make informed decisions about their VA benefits appeals.
Need personalized guidance on Supplemental Claim Appeals?