Understanding Your VA Rating Decision

Also known as: rating decision, decision letter, rating letter, understanding my rating, what does my rating mean, code sheet, rating narrative, favorable findings

Have a specific question about Understanding Your VA Rating Decision?

Ask Our AI Assistant

Free. Answers cite their sources, such as 38 CFR, VA.gov and other veterans-benefits references.

Overview

Overview

VA rating decisions consist of two main documents:

  1. Narrative - The document you receive in the mail
  2. Codesheet - An internal VBA master record

Rating Decision Narrative - 1. Basic Information

Rating Decision Narrative

The narrative explains how raters reached their decisions and contains five major sections:

1. Basic Information

Contains your name, file number, and any listed representative.

Rating Decision Narrative - 3. Decision Summaries

2. Introduction

Lists your branch(es) and service period(s), identifies relevant claims and appeals being addressed.

3. Decision Summaries

Shows what was granted, denied, or deferred with effective dates and evaluation percentages.

Rating Decision Narrative - 4. Evidence List

4. Evidence List

Documents everything the rater formally considered. Note: Not every piece of evidence must be listed, but important missing evidence could warrant a Higher Level Review (HLR).

Rating Decision Narrative - 5. Reasons and Basis

5. Reasons and Basis

Grants (Short-Form)

Three main parts: - Basis of grant (direct, secondary, presumptive, etc.) - Effective date(s) - Evaluation and requirements for next higher rating

Long-Form Decisions: Clear and Unmistakable Errors (CUE), Traumatic Brain Injuries (TBI), and Section 1151 denials require detailed long-form decisions where the rater explains all evidence considered, which elements of service connection were met, how they were met, and which were not met.

Denials (Short-Form)

Three main parts: - Service-connection theories considered - Explanation of decision - Any favorable findings already met

Deferrals

Occur when raters cannot make a complete decision. Common reasons include missing federal records, unavailable private medical records, or pending medical examinations.

Rating Decision Codesheet - 1. Data Tables

1. Data Tables

Basic service information, representative details, decision date. Legacy codes box includes combat codes and future exam dates.

Combat Codes (have NO impact on evaluations): - 1 = No combat-incurred conditions - 2 = All combat conditions rated 10%+ - 3 = All combat conditions rated 0% - 4 = Mixed combat ratings (0% and above)

Rating Decision Codesheet - 2. Jurisdiction/Associated Claims

2. Jurisdiction/Associated Claims

Identifies the reason for decision and associated End Products (EPs).

Rating Decision Codesheet - 3. Coded Conclusion

3. Coded Conclusion

The core section listing: - Diagnostic codes used for each condition - Whether service connection was granted or denied - Special issues identified (text in brackets denoting special considerations) - Period of service condition was incurred in (Peacetime, Gulf War, Vietnam, etc.) — internal VBA bookkeeping only - Basis of grant (incurred/direct, secondary, presumptive). If combat-related, "-COMBAT" appears to the right of the basis - Whether the condition is static or has a Routine Future Examination scheduled (a future exam date means at least one condition is not considered static) - Evaluations and their effective dates. If the diagnostic code changed previously, the former code appears to the right - Historic and current combined evaluations, including which conditions have the bilateral factor applied - Ancillary decisions (adaptive auto, Specially Adapted Housing, Chapter 35 benefits) - Special Monthly Compensation (SMC) — shows granted SMCs, effective dates, and SMC pay code. The SMC pay code drives actual payment, so errors here result in incorrect payment

Combat Designation Note: While the combat designation has no impact on VA evaluation, if combat-related conditions were the basis for a medical board resulting in severance pay, this designation exempts the veteran from having to return that pay.

Rating Decision Codesheet - 5. Signature(s)

4. Special Notation Boxes/Templates

May include: - Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE) template - Special notation box (instructions, explanations) - Amputation rule template - Accrued grant template

5. Signature(s)

Shows who made the decision. Complex cases may have multiple signatures.

Important Notes

Important Notes

Evidence Issues: If critical evidence is missing from the evidence list, consider filing an HLR, particularly if it addresses noted gaps.

Denied Conditions with Evaluations: Sometimes conditions show evaluations despite denials. This typically occurs with pension claims or when raters forget to remove evaluations after changing decisions.

Codesheet Priority: If the codesheet is incorrect but narrative is correct, payment will reflect the codesheet error. The codesheet drives actual benefit payments.

FAQs

FAQs

Q: My condition shows an evaluation but was denied? A: Often used for pension determinations to show potential rating if service-connection were granted, or accidental rater oversight that doesn't affect current benefits.

Q: How do I get my narrative? A: Access through VA.gov's claim letters portal.

Q: How do I get my codesheet? A: Request your complete claim file from VBA.

Source: veteransbenefitskb.com

Need personalized guidance on Understanding Your VA Rating Decision?

Ask Veterans Benefits AI

Answers cite their sources, so you can check them. AI can make mistakes.

Information from the Veterans Benefits Knowledge Base (veteransbenefitskb.com). Check the original source before you rely on it. Original source.

This page is for informational purposes only and is not legal or medical advice. AI-generated answers can contain errors.

Veterans Benefits AI is an independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.

© 2026 Veterans Benefits AI