Proposed Rating Reductions

Also known as: proposed reduction, rating reduction, VA reducing rating, fight reduction, reduction proposal, 60 day response, rating decrease, protect my rating

Have a specific question about Proposed Rating Reductions?

Ask Our AI Assistant

Free. Answers cite their sources, such as 38 CFR, VA.gov and other veterans-benefits references.

What to Do

What to Do

  1. Take a deep breath - This is stressful, but procedures exist to handle this situation.

  2. Request a personal hearing IMMEDIATELY - The VA will continue paying you at your current combined disability rate until the reduction process finishes, but only if you request a hearing quickly.

  3. Upload a personal statement via eAuth VA

  4. Develop a winning strategy while awaiting your hearing:

  5. Review the decision letter explaining the VA's proposed reduction
  6. Obtain additional medical evidence, DBQs, personal statements, and buddy statements
  7. Upload evidence before your hearing

  8. Attend your predetermination hearing - This can last up to one hour and is your opportunity to argue against the proposal. The hearing process is not adversarial.

  9. After the hearing, a determination will be made. If you disagree, you can appeal (though you won't maintain your former pay rate during appeal).

What to Do - Critical Notes

Critical Notes

Debt Considerations

Debt Considerations

Most finalized reductions don't create debt because effective dates are typically future-dated, not retroactive.

Important: No debts are created in Clear and Unmistakable Error (CUE) cases.

Debt Considerations - Requesting Debt Waiver

Requesting Debt Waiver

If a debt occurs and creates financial hardship: 1. Complete a written statement explaining why you shouldn't be responsible 2. Submit via eAuth VA

Incompetence

Incompetence

Most incompetence proposals stem from mental health examiner findings that the veteran "cannot manage financial affairs." However, many examiners provide insufficient reasoning.

Legal standard: A person must "lack the mental capacity to contract or manage affairs, including handling funds without limitation" due to injury or disease.

Key principle: When reasonable doubt exists regarding mental competency, such doubt must be resolved in favor of competency.

Incompetence - Defense Strategy

Defense Strategy

If found incompetent, you'll be required to have a fiduciary manage your benefits.

Reductions Without Due Process

Reductions Without Due Process

The VA can reduce ratings without due process if the combined rating doesn't change. In this case, you must appeal through normal procedures.

Exception: If a single decision increases then decreases your combined rating no lower than your original rating, due process is not required.

Severing Service-Connection

Severing Service-Connection

Service-connection removal is treated seriously and cannot be based solely on condition improvement.

Severing Service-Connection - Common Severance Grounds

Common Severance Grounds

Rating/Service-Connection Protections

Rating/Service-Connection Protections

Veterans holding ratings for extended periods have legal protections against reductions and severances: - 5-year rule: Ratings in effect for 5+ years cannot be reduced unless sustained improvement is shown - 10-year rule: Service connection cannot be severed after 10 years except for fraud - 20-year rule: Ratings in effect for 20+ years cannot be reduced below the lowest rating held during that period

Frequently Asked Questions

Frequently Asked Questions

Hearing format options? Yes - in-person, phone, or virtual (webcam) hearings may be available.

Mileage reimbursement? No, the VA does not reimburse veterans for mileage to hearings.

Can I have representation? Yes, a VSO (Veterans Service Organization) or attorney can represent you.

Back pay if I win? Yes, if your pay was reduced or if restoring your rating would increase your combined rating.

Missed the 30-day window? You can still request a hearing, though the VA isn't obligated to grant one before making a decision in most cases.

Submit evidence without a hearing? Yes, upload evidence via eAuth VA.

If service-connection is severed? Secondary conditions will also be proposed for severance.

Who makes the final decision? In most cases, the rater conducting your hearing makes the final decision.

Are hearings recorded? Yes.

New evidence during the hearing? Yes, but submit it shortly after - either upload online or provide to the VA public contact team before leaving.

References

References

Source: veteransbenefitskb.com

Need personalized guidance on Proposed Rating Reductions?

Ask Veterans Benefits AI

Answers cite their sources, so you can check them. AI can make mistakes.

Information from the Veterans Benefits Knowledge Base (veteransbenefitskb.com). Check the original source before you rely on it. Original source.

This page is for informational purposes only and is not legal or medical advice. AI-generated answers can contain errors.

Veterans Benefits AI is an independent 501(c)(3) nonprofit. It is not affiliated with or endorsed by the U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs.

© 2026 Veterans Benefits AI