Also known as: duty to assist, evidence requirements, 3.159 duty to assist, VA notice requirements, VCAA notice, what evidence VA needs, duty to notify, development letter
Have a specific question about Evidence Requirements and Duty to Assist?
The Department of Veterans Affairs (VA) has a statutory and regulatory duty to assist veterans and claimants in obtaining evidence necessary to substantiate claims for VA benefits. This guide summarizes the key provisions of the VA’s duty to assist and evidence requirements as codified in 38 CFR §§ 3.150 through 3.161. It explains how claims are filed, the types of claims, what evidence VA must obtain, when VA must provide medical examinations, and how veterans can enforce their rights if VA fails to meet its duty.
38 CFR 3.150 Forms and Filing Claims - Key Provisions (§ 3.150)
Key Provisions (§ 3.150)
Application Forms Furnished Upon Request
VA must provide the appropriate application form to any person applying for benefits, either in person or in writing.
Authority: 38 U.S.C. § 5102.
Forms Upon Veteran’s Death
Upon notice of a veteran’s death, VA forwards application forms to dependents with apparent entitlement to benefits (pension, compensation, DIC).
If no apparent dependent, forms are sent to the preferred dependent for accrued benefits.
Time limits for filing are included with the forms.
Cross-reference: Extension of time limits under § 3.109(b).
38 CFR 3.155 Intent to File and Informal Claims - How to File a Claim (§ 3.155)
How to File a Claim (§ 3.155)
Request for Application (§ 3.155(a))
A communication or action indicating desire to file benefits but not constituting a complete claim is treated as a request for an application form.
VA must notify the claimant of information needed to complete the application.
Intent to File a Claim (§ 3.155(b))
A claimant or authorized representative may submit an intent to file claim to preserve an effective date.
Must include sufficient identifiable or biographical information to identify the claimant.
VA provides the appropriate application form upon receipt.
If a complete application is received within 1 year of the intent to file, the effective date is the date VA received the intent.
38 CFR 3.155 Intent to File and Informal Claims - Methods to Submit Intent to File (§ 3.155(b)(1))
Methods to Submit Intent to File (§ 3.155(b)(1))
Saved Electronic Application
Application saved but not completed electronically via VA’s claims portal.
Written Intent on Prescribed Form
Signed and dated intent to file claim form submitted to VA.
Oral Intent to Designated VA Personnel
Oral statement to VA employee designated to receive such claims, documented in claimant’s records.
38 CFR 3.155 Intent to File and Informal Claims - Additional Notes
Additional Notes
Intent to file must identify the general benefit (e.g., compensation, pension).
Identification of specific conditions is optional and has no legal effect on the intent itself.
38 CFR 3.156 New and Relevant Evidence for Supplemental Claims - Definitions (§ 3.156)
Definitions (§ 3.156)
New Evidence: Evidence not previously part of the record before VA adjudicators.
Material Evidence: Evidence that relates to an unestablished fact necessary to substantiate the claim and is not cumulative or redundant.
38 CFR 3.156 New and Relevant Evidence for Supplemental Claims - Claims to Reopen (§ 3.156(a))
Claims to Reopen (§ 3.156(a))
A legacy claim may be reopened by submitting new and material evidence.
New and material evidence must raise a reasonable possibility of substantiating the claim.
38 CFR 3.156 New and Relevant Evidence for Supplemental Claims - Pending Legacy Claims (§ 3.156(b))
Pending Legacy Claims (§ 3.156(b))
New and material evidence received before the appeal period expires or appellate decision is issued will be considered part of the pending claim.
38 CFR 3.156 New and Relevant Evidence for Supplemental Claims - Service Department Records (§ 3.156(c))
Service Department Records (§ 3.156(c))
VA must reconsider a claim if it receives or associates relevant official service department records not previously associated at the time of the original decision, including:
Service records related to claimed in-service events or injuries, even if the veteran is not named.
Additional records forwarded by DoD or service departments after VA’s original request.
Declassified records previously unavailable due to classification.
Records not obtainable because they did not exist or claimant failed to provide sufficient information are excluded.
Retroactive awards based on such records require adequate medical evidence.
Be in writing or electronic format prescribed by VA.
Include sufficient information to allow VA to process the claim.
Records VA Must Obtain - Mandatory Records (§ 3.159(b))
Mandatory Records (§ 3.159(b))
Military Service Records: Service treatment records, personnel records, and other official military documents.
VA Records: Prior claims files, medical records, and benefit history.
Social Security Administration (SSA) Records: When relevant to the claim.
Private Medical Records: Only if the claimant provides a signed release authorizing VA to obtain them.
Records VA Must Obtain - Claimant’s Responsibility
Claimant’s Responsibility
Claimants must provide sufficient information to identify and locate records.
Failure to provide necessary releases or information may limit VA’s ability to assist.
When VA Must Provide a Medical Examination - Requirements (§ 3.159(b)(2))
Requirements (§ 3.159(b)(2))
VA must provide a medical examination or obtain a medical opinion when:
- There is evidence of a current disability or symptoms.
- There is evidence of an event, injury, or disease in service or a link to service.
- The evidence is insufficient to decide the claim.
- A medical examination is necessary to make a decision.
When VA Must Provide a Medical Examination - Exceptions
Exceptions
If the existing evidence is sufficient for a decision, VA may deny the claim without an exam.
If the claimant refuses to attend a VA exam without good cause, VA may deny the claim.
When the Duty to Assist Is Satisfied - Satisfaction of Duty (§ 3.159(d))
Satisfaction of Duty (§ 3.159(d))
VA’s duty to assist is satisfied when:
VA has made reasonable efforts to obtain relevant records.
VA has provided necessary medical examinations or opinions.
VA has notified the claimant of any outstanding evidence needed.
VA has considered all evidence of record.
When the Duty to Assist Is Satisfied - Reasonable Efforts Defined
Reasonable Efforts Defined
VA must make at least one request to obtain records from official sources.
If records are unavailable or do not exist, VA’s duty is satisfied.
Enforcing the Duty to Assist - If VA Fails to Assist
If VA Fails to Assist
Claimants may:
Submit a Notice of Disagreement (NOD) to appeal VA’s decision.
Request a Board of Veterans’ Appeals (BVA) hearing.
File a supplemental claim with new and relevant evidence.
File a Motion for Reconsideration or seek review under the Appeals Modernization Act (AMA).
Enforcing the Duty to Assist - Legal Remedies
Legal Remedies
Veterans may seek judicial review in the U.S. Court of Appeals for Veterans Claims (CAVC).
The court can remand claims for VA to fulfill its duty to assist.
Enforcing the Duty to Assist - Tips for Claimants
Tips for Claimants
Keep copies of all communications with VA.
Submit all relevant evidence and releases promptly.
Request VA to provide medical exams if needed.
Consult accredited Veterans Service Organizations (VSOs) or attorneys for assistance.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q1: What is an Intent to File a Claim and why is it important?
Q1: What is an Intent to File a Claim and why is it important?
A1: An Intent to File is a preliminary communication to VA indicating a desire to file a claim. It preserves the effective date for benefits for up to one year while the claimant completes and submits a formal application.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q2: Can VA deny my claim if I do not provide private medical records?
Q2: Can VA deny my claim if I do not provide private medical records?
A2: VA cannot obtain private records without your signed release. If you do not provide the release or records, VA may deny the claim if evidence is insufficient.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q3: When will VA provide me a medical examination?
Q3: When will VA provide me a medical examination?
A3: VA must provide a medical exam if there is evidence of a current disability, a link to service, and insufficient evidence to decide the claim.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q4: What happens if VA does not fulfill its duty to assist?
Q4: What happens if VA does not fulfill its duty to assist?
A4: You can appeal the decision, request a hearing, or seek judicial review. The court can order VA to comply with its duty to assist.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q5: What is new and material evidence?
Q5: What is new and material evidence?
A5: New evidence is evidence not previously in the record. Material evidence relates to an unestablished fact necessary to substantiate the claim and is not cumulative or redundant.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q6: How long does VA have to process an Intent to File?
Q6: How long does VA have to process an Intent to File?
A6: VA considers the complete claim filed as of the date the intent was received if the complete application is submitted within one year.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q7: Does VA have to get my Social Security records?
Q7: Does VA have to get my Social Security records?
A7: Yes, if relevant to the claim, VA must make reasonable efforts to obtain SSA records.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs) - Q8: Can I submit an informal claim?
Q8: Can I submit an informal claim?
A8: Yes, informal claims or requests for application forms are accepted but do not start the formal claim process until completed.
This guide is intended to assist veterans, dependents, and representatives in understanding VA’s duty to assist and evidence requirements under 38 CFR §§ 3.150–3.161. For specific cases, consult VA or accredited representatives.
Need personalized guidance on Evidence Requirements and Duty to Assist?